Pin it
Oh my goodness, these peppermint meltaway cookies have completely stolen my family's hearts! I first discovered this recipe during last year's holiday baking marathon, and now they're the most requested treat in my kitchen. They truly live up to their name, dissolving like little bites of winter magic with the most heavenly combination of buttery softness and festive peppermint. That pretty pink candy cane frosting on top? It makes them almost too pretty to eat almost!
What Makes These Special
You know how some cookies just make you close your eyes and smile? That's exactly what these do! The texture is absolutely incredible light as air and literally melting the moment they hit your tongue. I love watching people try them for the first time their eyes always light up at that first perfectly pepperminty bite. The crushed candy canes add such a lovely little crunch against the cloud-like cookie below.
Easy as Holiday Pie!
Let me tell you what I love most about these cookies they're actually so simple to make! You won't need to dig out every bowl in your kitchen one bowl for cookies and one for frosting is all it takes. And unlike those fussy sugar cookies that need to chill forever, these only need a quick 30-minute timeout in the fridge. Perfect for when the kids are begging to help with holiday baking!
Pin it
Let's Talk Ingredients
- Butter: Make sure it's sitting out on your counter before you start! Room temperature butter is the secret to that perfect texture.
- Confectioners' Sugar: This fine sugar is what gives us that melt-in-your-mouth magic.
- Egg Yolk: Just one yolk keeps everything held together beautifully.
- Extracts: I use both vanilla and peppermint don't skip either one!
- Flour and Cornstarch: This dynamic duo creates our perfectly tender texture.
- Baking Powder: Just enough to give us that gentle puff.
- Salt: A little pinch makes all the sweet flavors sing.
Let's Make Cookie Magic
Here's my foolproof method: after mixing up your dough, pop it in the fridge for just 30 minutes. I usually use this time to clean up and get my baking sheets ready! When you're shaping the cookies, think of making little snowballs that you gently press down. They won't spread much in the oven, so what you see is what you'll get!
The Frosting Fun
The buttercream is where we get to play! I love watching the transformation as my mixer whips the butter into clouds of pepperminty perfection. A tiny drop of pink food coloring makes them look so festive, but sometimes I leave them white and let the candy cane sprinkles add all the color. My daughter always sneaks a taste test at this point can't blame her!
My Favorite Tools
Let me share my cookie-making must-haves! My trusty electric mixer is the real MVP here it makes the smoothest frosting you've ever seen. I line all my baking sheets with silicone mats they're worth every penny for perfectly baked cookies. And that little cookie scoop I picked up at the baking store? Total game-changer for getting perfectly matched cookies!
Pin it
Frosting Like a Pro
Don't worry about making these look perfect! I've found that a simple butter knife works just fine for spreading the frosting, though I do love using my piping bag when I'm feeling fancy. Just make sure your cookies are completely cool first I learned that the hard way during last year's Christmas party when all my frosting started sliding off!
Keeping Them Fresh
These little beauties stay perfect in an airtight container on my counter for about a week though they rarely last that long in my house! If you want to make them last even longer pop them in the fridge. Just remember to let them come back to room temperature before serving that's when they have that perfect melt-in-your-mouth texture we're looking for!
Party Perfect
Every holiday gathering I host, these cookies steal the show! I love arranging them on my grandmother's vintage cookie plate next to a pot of hot cocoa. Last Christmas, I packaged them in pretty boxes with ribbon for teacher gifts my daughter's art teacher asked for the recipe before winter break even started!
Pin it
Making Them Your Own
While I adore the classic peppermint version, sometimes I get creative in my kitchen! My sister loves when I add a hint of cinnamon to the dough, and my chocolate-loving son convinced me to try a white chocolate drizzle instead of frosting. That's what I love about baking making each recipe your very own!
Holiday Baking Joy
You know what makes these cookies extra special? They bring everyone into the kitchen! My kids love crushing the candy canes (in a sealed bag, of course less mess!), and decorating day has become one of our favorite holiday traditions. There's something magical about creating these sweet treats together.
Fancy It Up
Sometimes I get extra creative with the decorating especially for special occasions! Last year I swirled pink and white frosting together for a candy cane effect it looked so pretty! My neighbor taught me to sprinkle some edible glitter on top talk about holiday sparkle! These little touches make each cookie feel like a tiny celebration.
Perfect Pairings
In our house, these cookies are always served with something warm to sip. My husband loves them with his evening coffee, the kids prefer hot chocolate with extra marshmallows, and I'm partial to a cozy cup of peppermint tea. There's just something about that combination that makes winter evenings feel extra special.
Pin it
Everyone Can Enjoy!
Over the years I've adapted this recipe for all my friends' dietary needs. My gluten-free version using a special flour blend turned out wonderfully! And when my vegan niece visits, I use plant-based butter and an egg replacer. The joy on their faces when they can enjoy cookies with everyone else makes the extra effort so worth it.
Baking Together
These cookies have become a wonderful teaching tool in my kitchen! My grandkids learn about measuring, mixing, and patience while we bake together. Even my teenager, who usually lives on his phone, gets excited about our cookie-making afternoons. It's amazing how baking brings generations together!
Mindful Baking
I try to be thoughtful about my baking choices these days. I source my vanilla from a local shop, use organic powdered sugar when I can find it, and save pretty tins throughout the year for holiday gifting. My kitchen may not be perfectly zero-waste, but every small choice helps make our baking traditions a bit more earth-friendly for the next generation of cookie makers!
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why is cornstarch essential in this recipe?
- Cornstarch is key for creating the signature meltaway texture. It helps make the cookies tender and gives them that unique melt-in-your-mouth quality that sets them apart from regular cookies.
- → Can I skip the chilling time?
- No, chilling the dough for at least 30 minutes is crucial. The chilling time helps prevent the cookies from spreading too much and ensures they keep their shape while baking.
- → How do I know when the cookies are done baking?
- The cookies won't darken or brown much, so look for set edges after 13-14 minutes. Be careful not to overbake as this can affect their soft texture.
- → Can I make these cookies ahead of time?
- You can make the dough up to 3 days ahead and store it in the fridge. The baked and frosted cookies keep at room temperature for 1 day or in the fridge for 5 days.
- → Why shouldn't I freeze the baked cookies?
- Freezing the baked cookies affects their delicate texture. While you can freeze the unbaked dough balls, the finished cookies won't have the same meltaway quality after freezing and thawing.